Starch sugar hypothesis
The starch-sugar hypothesis is one of the older explanations for the mechanism of stomatal opening and closing in plants, primarily focusing on the osmotic changes within guard cells driven by the interconversion of starch and sugars.
Here's a breakdown of the hypothesis:
### Starch-Sugar Hypothesis of Stomatal Movement
This hypothesis, proposed by Lloyd (1908) and later refined by Sayre (1926), suggests that light-driven changes in the pH of guard cells lead to the interconversion of insoluble starch and soluble sugars, which in turn alters the osmotic potential and turgor of the guard cells, controlling stomatal aperture.
#### 1. Mechanism During the Day (Stomatal Opening)
* **Photosynthesis and pH Increase:** During the day, guard cells perform photosynthesis, consuming carbon dioxide (CO2). This leads to a decrease in CO2 concentration within the guard cells, which in turn causes an increase in their pH (becomes more alkaline).
* CO2 + H2O ⇌ H2CO3 (carbonic acid) ⇌ H+ + HCO3-
* Reducing CO2 shifts the equilibrium to the left, decreasing H+ and increasing pH.
* **Starch to Sugar Conversion:** The increased (alkaline) pH activates the enzyme **phosphorylase**. This enzyme catalyzes the hydrolysis of insoluble starch stored in the guard cells into glucose-1-phosphate, which is then converted into glucose and fructose (soluble sugars).
* Starch (insoluble) + inorganic phosphate $\overrightarrow{\text{Phosphorylase, high pH}}$ Glucose-1-phosphate (soluble sugar)
* **Increased Osmotic Potential:** The accumulation of soluble sugars within the guard cells significantly increases their solute concentration, making their sap more concentrated.
* **Water Influx and Turgor:** This higher solute concentration lowers the water potential inside the guard cells. Consequently, water moves by osmosis from the subsidiary cells (or surrounding epidermal cells) into the guard cells. The influx of water increases turgor pressure within the guard cells, causing them to bow outwards and open the stomatal pore.
#### 2. Mechanism During the Night (Stomatal Closing)
* **Respiration and pH Decrease:** At night, photosynthesis ceases, but respiration continues. This produces CO2, which accumulates in the guard cells. The increased CO2 concentration lowers the pH (becomes more acidic).
* **Sugar to Starch Conversion:** The decreased (acidic) pH inactivates or reverses the action of phosphorylase, promoting the synthesis of insoluble starch from soluble sugars.
* Soluble Sugars $\overrightarrow{\text{Phosphorylase, low pH}}$ Starch (insoluble)
* **Decreased Osmotic Potential:** The conversion of soluble sugars back into insoluble starch reduces the solute concentration within the guard cells.
* **Water Efflux and Turgor Loss:** This higher water potential inside the guard cells causes water to move out of the guard cells, into the surrounding epidermal or subsidiary cells, by osmosis. The loss of water leads to a decrease in turgor pressure, causing the guard cells to become flaccid and close the stomatal pore.
### Limitations
While the starch-sugar hypothesis offered an initial framework, it has several limitations and is largely superseded by more comprehensive models:
* **Speed of Movement:** The conversion of starch to sugar is generally too slow to account for the rapid stomatal movements observed in plants.
* **Lack of Starch:** Many plants, particularly grasses, have guard cells that contain little to no starch, yet still exhibit stomatal movements.
* **Primary Driving Force:** Modern research indicates that the influx and efflux of potassium (K+) ions are the primary drivers of turgor changes in guard cells, with sugars playing a supplementary role.
The K+ ion pump hypothesis, which explains how guard cells actively transport K+ ions in and out, is now considered the dominant mechanism for stomatal regulation.