Physical force theory

-

 I'll search for comprehensive information about the physical force theories of ascent of sap.## Physical Force Theories of Ascent of Sap

Physical force theories propose that the upward movement of sap is driven by purely physical forces rather than the activity of living cells. These theories argue that even dead cells can transport water through mechanical and physical mechanisms.

Major Physical Force Theories

1. Root Pressure Theory (Priestley, 1916)

Mechanism:

  • Active absorption of water by root cells creates positive pressure in the xylem
  • This pressure pushes water upward from roots to aerial parts
  • Pressure develops due to osmotic accumulation of ions in root xylem

Evidence Supporting:

  • Guttation (water droplets on leaf margins) observed in early morning
  • Bleeding or exudation from cut stems
  • Root pressure can be measured (typically 1-2 bars or atmospheres)

Fatal Objections:

  • Root pressure magnitude in most plants does not exceed 0.1 MPa while a top to bottom pressure difference of about 2.2 MPa or 22 atm is needed to raise water to the top of tall trees.
  • Root pressure is not observed in most conifers and other gymnosperms, where water has to travel for a long vertical distance.
  • Root pressure is absent during rapid transpiration when water demand is highest
  • Strasburger showed water continues to rise even without roots

2. Capillary Force Theory (Boehm, 1809)

Mechanism:

  • Xylem vessels act as narrow capillary tubes
  • Surface tension and adhesive forces between water and xylem walls cause water to rise
  • Similar to how water rises in a glass capillary tube

How Capillarity Works:

  • Water molecules adhere to the walls of narrow tubes
  • Surface tension creates an upward pull
  • The narrower the tube, the higher water can rise

Fatal Objections:

  • Capillary action can raise water only about 1 meter in tubes the size of xylem vessels
  • A xylem vessel with a bore of 0.02mm is capable of lifting water to a maximum height of 150cm. This fails to explain tall trees
  • If capillarity were the mechanism, the tallest trees should have the narrowest vessels, but anatomical evidence shows otherwise
  • Xylem vessels don't have free water surfaces as required for capillary action
  • Vessels are not directly open to soil water

3. Atmospheric Pressure Theory

Mechanism:

  • Transpiration from leaves creates a vacuum in xylem vessels
  • Atmospheric pressure (1 atm = 10 meters of water column) pushes water up from below to fill the vacuum

Fatal Objections:

  • Atmospheric pressure can lift water up to a height of 10 meters. This is insufficient for tall trees
  • Requires a perfect vacuum at the top, which doesn't exist
  • Atmospheric pressure acts on water at the base, but xylem vessels aren't directly exposed to atmospheric pressure at the root level
  • Cannot explain water movement in trees over 10 meters tall

4. Imbibition Force Theory (Sachs, 1878-79)

Mechanism:

  • Water moves upward through imbibition in the cell walls of xylem elements
  • Cell wall materials (cellulose, lignin) have strong water-absorbing properties
  • Imbibition pressure can reach very high values (up to 1000 atmospheres)

Fatal Objections:

  • Experimental evidence with dyes (eosin, fuchsine) proved water moves through the lumen (hollow interior) of xylem vessels, not through the walls
  • When xylem cavities were blocked with paraffin, water movement stopped completely
  • It is already proved that the ascent of sap occurs through the lumen of the xylem vessels and not through the walls of the xylem.

Why Physical Force Theories (Except Cohesion-Tension) Failed

None of the above physical theories could adequately explain:

  1. Height Problem: Water ascent in very tall trees (100+ meters in redwoods, eucalyptus)
  2. Speed Problem: The rapid rate of water transport observed in plants
  3. Continuous Transport: Movement during both day and night, with and without roots
  4. Experimental Evidence: Dye tracing and other experiments contradicted their predictions

The Successful Physical Theory: Cohesion-Tension Theory

Proposed by: Dixon and Joly (1894), elaborated by Dixon (1914)

This is the only physical force theory that successfully explains ascent of sap and is universally accepted today.

Core Mechanism:

The theory combines three physical properties:

  1. Transpiration Pull (Tension):

    • Water evaporates from mesophyll cells in leaves during transpiration
    • This creates negative pressure (tension) in the leaf xylem
    • Tension can reach very high values (up to -30 bars)

  2. Cohesion (Water-Water Forces):

    • Water molecules held together due to strong cohesive forces form a long continuous water column in xylem vessels, extending from the root to the leaves.
    • Hydrogen bonding between water molecules creates enormous tensile strength
    • Theoretical cohesive strength: ~15,000 atmospheres
    • Measured values in xylem: 45-300 atmospheres

  3. Adhesion (Water-Wall Forces):

    • Water molecules adhere to hydrophilic xylem walls
    • Prevents the water column from breaking away from vessel walls
    • Helps maintain column continuity

Step-by-Step Process:

LEAVES (Top)
↓
1. Transpiration from stomata
2. Water loss from mesophyll cells
3. Decreased water potential in leaf cells
4. Water pulled from leaf xylem
5. Tension created in xylem
↓
STEM (Middle)
↓
6. Tension transmitted downward through continuous water column
7. Cohesion keeps water molecules together
8. Adhesion keeps water column attached to walls
↓
ROOT (Bottom)
↓
9. Tension reaches root xylem
10. Water pulled from root cortex
11. Water absorbed from soil

Key Advantages:

✓ Explains water ascent to any height (proven in 100+ meter trees)
✓ No metabolic energy required in xylem (dead cells sufficient)
✓ Explains rapid transport rates
✓ Consistent with all experimental evidence
✓ Works in plants with and without root pressure

Popular posts from this blog

transport of metabolites from source to sink

-
  The transport of metabolites from a source to a sink location, primarily in plants, is a crucial process for nutrient distribution and growth. This process is mainly carried out by the   phloem , a vascular tissue. Here's a breakdown of the process: 1. Defining Source and Sink Source:  Any part of the plant that produces or releases metabolites in excess of its own needs, typically through photosynthesis or storage breakdown. Primary sources include mature leaves (producing sugars) and storage organs during mobilization (e.g., tubers converting starch to sugar). Sink:  Any part of the plant that consumes or stores metabolites. Sinks include growing regions (e.g., roots, young leaves, developing fruits, flowers, shoot tips), and storage organs during accumulation (e.g., tubers, fruits). 2. The Phloem Transport System The phloem consists mainly of: Sieve tube elements:  Living cells that form the transport pathway, specialized for bulk flow by lacking a nucleus ...
Read more

STRESS RELATED PROTEIN IN PLANT STRESS PHYSIOLOGY

-
  In plant stress physiology, stress-related proteins are a diverse group of proteins whose synthesis is upregulated or whose activity is altered in response to various environmental stressors. These proteins play crucial roles in enabling plants to perceive, respond to, and ultimately survive adverse conditions. Here are key types and their functions: ### Key Categories of Stress-Related Proteins 1. **Heat Shock Proteins (HSPs)** * **Function:** Act as molecular chaperones, helping to prevent the denaturation and aggregation of other proteins under heat stress and assisting in the refolding of misfolded proteins. They are also involved in protein transport and degradation. * **Examples:** HSP100, HSP90, HSP70, HSP60, and Small HSPs (sHSPs). Present in all cellular compartments. 2. **Late Embryogenesis Abundant (LEA) Proteins** * **Function:** Synthesized during dehydration stress (e.g., drought, salinity, freezing). They are largely hydrophilic and believed...
Read more

Chelating agents

-
  Chelating agents in plants play a crucial role in nutrient dynamics and heavy metal detoxification. They are organic molecules that can bind to metal ions, forming a stable, water-soluble complex called a chelate. This process significantly influences the availability and movement of essential micronutrients and toxic heavy metals within the plant and its environment. Here are the key functions of chelating agents in plants: Enhancing Micronutrient Availability and Uptake: Solubilization:  Many essential metal micronutrients (e.g., iron (Fe), zinc (Zn), manganese (Mn), copper (Cu)) exist in the soil in forms that are insoluble or poorly available for plant uptake, especially in alkaline soils. Chelating agents bind to these metal ions, converting them into soluble complexes that plants can more easily absorb through their roots. Transport:  Once absorbed, chelating agents can facilitate the transport of these metals from the roots to other parts of the plant (stems, lea...
Read more