Starch sugar hypothesis long answer
Today at 2:38 PM
Show Thinking Process
The Starch-Sugar Hypothesis, also known as the Starch Hydrolysis Theory or Guard Cell Starch-Sugar Interconversion Theory, was an early and influential model proposed to explain the mechanism of stomatal opening and closing in plants, primarily attributed to J.D. Sayre and later G. Sayre and H. Scarth in the 1930s.
Core Principle
The central idea is that the interconversion of insoluble starch (a storage polysaccharide) and soluble sugars (like glucose) within the guard cells directly regulates their osmotic potential. This change in osmotic potential, in turn, drives the influx or efflux of water, leading to changes in guard cell turgor and thus stomatal movement.
Proposed Mechanism
The hypothesis linked the pH changes within the guard cells, influenced by photosynthesis and respiration, to the enzymatic conversion of starch and sugar.
1. Stomatal Opening (During the Day)
Photosynthesis in Guard Cells: During daylight, guard cells perform photosynthesis (though less efficiently than mesophyll cells). This process consumes carbon dioxide (CO2).
Decrease in CO2 and Increase in pH: The reduction in CO2 concentration within the guard cells leads to a decrease in carbonic acid (H2CO3) and H+ ions, resulting in an increase in the pH of the guard cell cytoplasm (becoming more alkaline, typically pH 7.0-7.5).
Starch Hydrolysis: This higher pH is believed to activate the enzyme phosphorylase (or an amylase), which catalyzes the hydrolysis (breakdown) of insoluble starch into soluble sugars, primarily glucose-1-phosphate, and then into glucose or other simple sugars.
Starch + H2O → Glucose-1-phosphate → Glucose (soluble sugars)
Increased Osmotic Potential: The accumulation of many small, soluble sugar molecules significantly increases the solute concentration and thus lowers the water potential (increases osmotic potential) inside the guard cells.
Water Influx and Turgor: Due to the lower water potential, water moves by osmosis from the surrounding epidermal cells (which have a higher water potential) into the guard cells. This influx of water increases the turgor pressure within the guard cells.
Stomata Open: As the guard cells become turgid, their unique cell wall structure (thicker inner walls, thinner outer walls, radial micellation of cellulose microfibrils) causes them to bow outwards, thereby opening the stomatal pore.
2. Stomatal Closing (During the Night or Stress)
No Photosynthesis: In the absence of light, photosynthesis ceases in the guard cells.
CO2 Accumulation and Decrease in pH: Respiration continues, producing CO2. Since CO2 is no longer being consumed by photosynthesis, it accumulates within the guard cells. This increased CO2 dissolves to form carbonic acid, leading to a decrease in cytoplasmic pH (becoming more acidic, typically pH 5.0-5.5).
Sugar Synthesis (Starch Formation): This lower pH is believed to favor the reverse reaction, where phosphorylase (or other enzymes) catalyzes the synthesis of starch from the soluble sugars.
Glucose → Glucose-1-phosphate → Starch
Decreased Osmotic Potential: The conversion of many small soluble sugar molecules into one large, insoluble starch molecule dramatically decreases the solute concentration and increases the water potential (decreases osmotic potential) inside the guard cells.
Water Efflux and Deturgor: Water moves by osmosis out of the guard cells and into the surrounding epidermal cells (which now have a relatively lower water potential). This loss of water causes the guard cells to lose turgor.
Stomata Close: As the guard cells become flaccid, they straighten or collapse inward, closing the stomatal pore.
Limitations and Modern Modifications
While the Starch-Sugar Hypothesis provided an initial framework, it faced several criticisms and has been largely superseded or significantly modified by more advanced research, particularly the "Potassium Ion (K+) Accumulation Theory."